Celebrating the Abundance of Local Foods, Season by Season

Delivered to Your Mailbox Each Season. Subscribe Today.

Delivered to Your Mailbox Each Season.
Subscribe Today.

Cooking with Carafoli: What Do You Do With a 3 1/2 Lobster For Two?

MENU:

Lobster Risotto

Heirloom Tomatoes & Curried Lobster

Lobster Gumbo

Peach Upside-Down Skillet Cake

It was a cool fall day, perfect for a fireplace dining experience. We call this dining in: appetizers by the fireplace, followed by dinner in our dining room. On this particular day, we decided dinner would feature Mexican cuisine, including Margaritas, guacamole, salsa, and chips. Additionally, I added blistered Shishito peppers. And of course, quiet Mexican music in the background.

Before all this took place, I had to buy the ingredients. Off to my fishmonger for the lobster, and the supermarket for limes and cilantro.

Due to the Labor Day holiday, the fish market was crowded – this is where the problem arose. I said, “I want a lobster, about 3½ pounds.” I am a visual person and clearly was not aware of what a 3½ pound lobster looked like. It was shoved into a bag with a lemon before I had a chance to see it. I got home and looked at the bill – $69 for a lobster! Shocked and afraid to bring this up to my husband, I panicked! He had already seen the bill on his iPhone. By the time I got home, everything was resolved. I told him we could have not just one great meal tonight but enough for three, plus stock for soup!

Although large lobsters are often said to be less tender, I have learned it is all in the way they are cooked. To prepare this 3½ pound lobster, split it (see photos) and season with cilantro lime butter. I placed it on a large baking sheet and put it in a preheated 425-degree Fahrenheit convection oven. It took approximately 25 to 30 minutes.

Save the Shells for a Lobster Stock

The head, body, shells, and legs are full of flavor and perfect for making a rich seafood gumbo or risotto.

Begin with a large 8- or 12-quart saucepan. Crush the cooked shells in the pan with a mallet or the back of a knife. Add 2 cups of dry white wine, followed by water to cover. Add one chopped onion, carrot, celery stalk, and a few herbs. Bring the mixture to a boil, then reduce the heat to medium, cover, and simmer for 1 hour. Strain the liquid to obtain the stock.

It is recommended to use this fish stock within several days due to its short lifespan.

Related Stories & Recipes:

You May Also Like:

Sign up to stay in touch!

View our Digital Edition

Stay in Touch

Join our Digital Food Community!

Sign up for monthly Cape Cod food news, updates, seasonal recipes, events, and more.